eul_wid: gww-ab

Chamaeleon of Heraclea Pontica Fragments on Poetic Criticism in Greek

The Fragments on Poetic Criticism is a lost treatise by the Hellenistic scholar Chamaeleon of Heraclea Pontica, a student of Aristotle active in the late fourth or early third century BCE. As a member of the Peripatetic school, Chamaeleon participated in its systematic study of literature and poetics. The work survives only in two brief fragments preserved by the later compiler Athenaeus in his Deipnosophistae. One fragment discusses the lyric poet Stesichorus, noting his criticism of Homer and Hesiod and recording the existence of two distinct versions of his famous Palinode. The other fragment, citing both Chamaeleon and the historian Istros, recounts an anecdote about the poet Pindar being visited by bees on Mount Helicon. These excerpts exemplify the Peripatetic method of collecting biographical anecdotes and rationalizing interpretations of poetic texts. The original treatise's full scope, structure, and content are otherwise unknown.

28 bis PAP. OX. 2506 fr. 26 col. 1, 2—12 (s. 1/2 p.; vol. 29, 1963, 10. 35f. [Taf. 4]; Lyrik.—Komment. [s. Stesich. F 16 〈mel. 193〉 Page = Lyrica Graeca selcta 35 〈Stesich. F 63〉]): [... μέμ]ˈφετα̣ι (Stesich.) τὸν [Ὅ̣μ̣]ηρο[ν, ὅτι Ἑˈλέ]νην [ἐ̣π̣]οίη̣σεν ἐ̣ν̣ [Τ̣ροίαι] ˈ καὶ οὐ τὸ εἴδωλον αὐτῆ[ς, ἔν] ˈ τε τ̣[ῆι] ἑτέραι τὸν Ἡσίοδ[ον] (F 358 not. Merk.—West) ˈ μέμ[φετ]αι. διτταὶ γάρ εἰσι Παˈλινω〈ι〉δ(ίαι) [ἀ]λλάτ̣τ̣ουσαι, καὶ ἔστιν 〈τ〉ῆ〈σ〉 μὲν 〈ἡ〉 ἀρχὴ̣ ‘δεῦ ⟦ τε ⟧ ρ’ αὖˈτε θεὰ φιλόμολπε‘, τῆς δὲ ˈ ‘χ̣ρυσόπτερε παρθέ̣ν̣ε‘, ⟦ ρ ⟧ ὡς ˈ ἀνέγραψε Χαμαι̣λ [ έ ω ]ν ...
32c PAP. OX. 2451 B fr. 1, 2—4 (s. 1—2 p.; vol. 26, 1961, 162 [Taf. 17]): ... Χ̣αμαιλέω [ ν καὶ Ἴστρος (334 F77 bis) φασὶ περὶ τὸν Ἑλι]κῶν̣α κυν̣[ηγετοῦντα αὐτὸν] (Pind.) [... προσπε]τομ̣ένα̣[ς] (scil.τὰς μελίσσας) ...